Managing Your Cash Flow
Avoiding falling prey to risky invoices
5 min read
23 March 2016
Charles Henri Royon, VP EMEA at Tradeshift, looks at how recent headlines have drawn attention to the issue of bogus invoices and provides some expert advice for business owners not wanting to become part of the story as well.
In the news during March 2016 we’ve heard that a boss is facing jail for submitting more than £3m worth of doctored client invoices, while a hotel manager has been convicted for falsifying documents worth £350,000. You may question how such an extortionate amount of money was swindled, but this type of activity is actually more common than many might think.
The Institute of Directors actually found that nearly three-quarters of UK businesses have received bogus invoices. Fraudsters are continually targeting companies, tricking each into sending payments to fake suppliers, and stories around rogue employees syphoning money into separate accounts often appear in the news too. We’re also seeing stories in the news about overseas scams pocketing cash through payments that don’t clear.
Most businesses will, of course, have firewalls and password practices in place to secure the organisation’s data. So why aren’t bosses taking similar precautions for their invoices?
It’s not necessarily easy – flagging fraudulent activity can be difficult, no matter the size and complexity of a company’s supply chain, whether SME or multinational. Much like how Airbnb verifies its users against an identification checklist, or PayPal safeguards sellers with good records by holding buyers’ payments for 21 days, businesses too need better controls, checks and visibility into supply chains, suppliers and payments.
Presuming that businesses would have taken the necessary precautions to assess whether suppliers are legitimate (checking they’re registered, verifying endorsements and scrutinising the website, for example), there are a few steps required to de-risk the invoicing process even further.
The first step is to educate employees on the different types of invoicing scams and the specific payment patterns to look at out for that may indicate fraud. Key fraud flags can include round pound value invoices, duplicate invoice payments, paying straight away and failing to match invoices. Management needs to create policies on how to act when such issues arise, such as reporting suspicious activity to their bank in order to block transfers.
Making supply chains more transparent is also essential and in an era of cloud platforms, and this can be achieved by digitising processes. Electronic invoices flag errors and omissions so that invoices with inaccuracies are not processed, which is where paper documents can fail.
Read more about Fraud:
- Former Enron CFO suggests fraud is now ten times worse
- History of boiler room scams dominated by British fraudsters and investors
- Supreme Court ruling suggests fraudulent activity by directors cannot be attributed to firms
Hosting payments on a cloud platform also means businesses have access to real-time supplier master data which provides a way to de-risk the supply chain even further. Businesses able to look for and flag unusual activity (like those I already touched upon) much easier because there aren’t mounds of paper to dig through – it’s all accessible online.
By connecting with suppliers over the cloud, businesses can also build a supplier check list for them to effectively validate themselves – somewhat mimicking a LinkedIn profile. If suppliers don’t tick off certain criteria, then companies know to avoid doing business with them.
Having a one-stop shop for supplier data also makes it much easier for businesses to regularly review supplier lists and make sure information is up to date. This way each can minimise duplicate suppliers and consolidate them when possible – avoiding payment errors – and also block those that have been inactive for say 18 months, which could signify a fraudulent company.
While we can never fully predict payment risks, we can certainly do more to prepare and avoid them. Educating employees, instilling processes and harnessing technology are all key steps for protecting a business – not only its purse strings but its reputation too.
Charles Henri Royon is VP EMEA at Tradeshift.