On the 2014 rundown, John Lewis stole the show with its Monty the Penguin advert, which achieved an emotionally compelling score of 84 per cent. That’s all changed this year, however, as the company fell to seventh place with people seemingly less impressed by its Man on the Moon effort.
Realeyes’ technology works by analysing the facial reactions of viewers via webcam to determine how engaged consumers are when observing content, based on four metrics attraction, retention, engagement and impact.
For its Christmas study, the Oxford University-founded company screened 30 festive ads from top brands to 1,500 Brits, resulting in more than 11.5m frames of facial expressions.
Climbing from second place in 2014 to the number one spot in 2015 was Harvey Nichols and its Avoid Gift Face ad, followed by Kwik Fit in second place and Currys in third.
According to Realeyes, both Harvey Nichols and Kwik-Fit secured places in the all-time top nine per cent of ads it has measured for emotional engagement a combined analysis of how well the ad does to grab the attention of, and leave an impact on, the viewer.
John Lewis remains the undisputed champion for publicity and hype but in terms of connecting emotionally with consumers, many brands outdid them this year,” said Realeyes CEO Mihkel J tma.
John Lewis ads have become increasingly out of this world and fantasy-based, consequently, theyre becoming harder to identify with. Were seeing a move away from the kind of heavy-handed emotional approach. Harvey Nichols, Kwik Fit and Currys did brilliantly because it was about situations weve all been in putting a brave face on disappointing gifts or seeing childrens reactions on meeting Santa.
The report also revealed that Harvey Nichols was the only Christmas ad this year to achieve a 10/10 score on the four emotional engagement metrics.
Additionally, the department store business also possesses the title of the most engaging Christmas ad to date for its 2013 advert, which ranks in the top three per cent of all ads measured by Realeyes.
The top ten most compelling Christmas ads are:
1. Harvey Nichols Avoid Gift Face, which scored 91.4 per cent better than all ads measured by Realeyes
2. Kwik Fit Santa Surprise, which scored 90.7 per cent better than all ads measured by Realeyes
3. Currys Santa Surprise, which scored 88.6 per cent better than all ads measured by Realeyes
Continue reading on the next page to find out which other companies outpaced John Lewis